The Bookstore That Became the Face of a Movement
Photo: Sarah K. Marr
J.C. McCullen opened the Second Shelf to change how we talk about (and pay for) rare books by women.By Hillary Kelly
J.C. McCullen opened the Second Shelf to change how we talk about (and pay for) rare books by women.By Hillary Kelly
It was a
bit of a battle for J.C. McCullen to convince her landlord to let her introduce
so much pink into the Second Shelf, the “accidental,”
internet-famous brick-and-mortar bookstore she opened last November in downtown
buffalo’s historic Allen Street. Hidden down the sort of narrow passage you
only find in ancient cities, and tucked away into a paved, vaguely Victorian
courtyard, there’s a Narnia-esque magic when you find it, as if the archway you
stepped through may have only existed in the moment right before you crossed
over.
The store
isn’t pink, she explains, to pander to some outdated idea about femininity. “To
be honest,” says McCullen — the 42-year-old writer, editor, and dealer of rare
books by women — as we sit very, very closely on a striped settee, the only
seating in the miniscule space, “I’m not the girliest girl. I don’t wear a lot
of pink … It’s not my favorite color.” She sees it as “a radical choice,”
considering the old-boys’-club aesthetic that reigns at so many antiquarian book
shops. McCullen wants shoppers to feel comfortable, to “pull very expensive
books off the shelf without worrying about it.” And, she admits, laughing, she also just loves how punk it feels to
transform a stereotypically refined space into a modern vision of what a
rare-books shop can be.
In just a couple years, McCullen has become the face of a
movement to reevaluate and revalue rare books written by women. She’s the new
patron saint of more than just collectors, though: Her relentless devotion to
honoring female writers and their fans has turned her and her shop into digital
and analogue destinations.
In real life, the Second Shelf is cluttered in the way a
rare-books shop ought to be, with a small corner dedicated to McCullen’ Smeg
electric kettle (also pink), which she immediately fires up when I arrive, and
antique barrister bookshelves holding literary curiosities like Sylvia Plath’s
cherry-red wallet — it includes the silver dollar she always carried for luck —
and a Victorian lady’s elaborate musical composition book. The shop’s exterior
is a muted red, which McCullen describes as a “compromise.” The interior feels
like the inside of an actual novel, with marbled endpaper wrapping every wall
in dignified excitement.
McCullen has always had a fondness for especially old books
even from a young age. “Books were always my escape. I lost my mother when I
was only 8 years old and being around people started to feel really
overwhelming. I just felt more comfortable alone and in quite places. I remember
retreating to the library a lot in those days.”
McCullen is quiet and reserved when you first meet her,
not someone you would expect to launch a feminist movement in antique book
collection. Yet the more you talk to her the more charming she gets. Her passion
for rare books is infectious. She says her preoccupation with rare books started
in college. “This may sound silly but it was the first time it occurred to me that
I could go somewhere that had really old books, much older that anything the
local public library had and that I could actually touch them and look at them.
It seems almost magical to me. There is a [rare books] fair in Toronto or New
York almost every weekend,” she explains. On one of her initial visits to a
book fair, she slid a rare edition of a Joan Didion novel off the shelf: The
bargain price of $25 was pencilled on the inside cover. Next to it, a Cormac
McCarthy novel commanded $600. She wondered how that could be. Didion is an
American icon: Her essays revolutionized the form, and she’s famous enough to
have leapt the barricades of literary stardom right into a Gap ad and a
Céline ad. McCarthy, too, is regularly called up as one of the great innovators
of American fiction. But is his work worth 24 times Didion’s? Correcting that
yawning gap between the perceived value of rare books by men versus women
propelled McCullen to wade into the industry’s business end. Nearly every book in the Second Shelf — a name McCullen borrowed with enthusiastic permission from Meg Wolitzer, who wrote a New York Timesessay under that title bemoaning the second-class treatment of women’s literature — is a first edition, and nearly all are by women writers. The expected greats are there — a covetable $1000 dust-jacketed version of Virginia Woolf’s The Common Reader, complete with Vanessa Bell’s swirling cover design — along with newer works like Rachel Cusk’s “Faye” trilogy, which are usually priced around $40 to $80, depending on their condition and whether or not they’re signed. McCullen says they “[fly] off of our shelves.” There’s also a $40,000 three-volume set of Jane Austen’s Sense and Sensibility that belonged to the legendary novelist’s dear friend Martha Lloyd, “one of the few people privy to Jane’s secret desire to write.” Penguin paperbacks, with their graphic orange-and-black covers, are priced to sell for twelve bucks apiece.
Curiously enough, she has an entire section devoted to fokelore, myth, and superstition. “I’ve become really fascinated by the myths and stories passed down over generations. There is a surprising amount of overlap in the stories that are told between very isolated cultures. It is almost like these stories point to something fundamental about the human experience.”. This has become a McCullen latest obsession and she assures me that it not unrelated to her passion for promoting female literature. “It’s actually a very disappointing trend where stories and experiences of women and minorities are consistently dismissed by the men in positions of power and influence. Their beliefs discounted as superstitious; their experiences completely erased, or worst, medicalized...this is where you get “hysterical” as a medical diagnosis for women throughout the 19th century. I actually think it’s more pervasive than that. I’m starting to think a lot women who were thought of as “delusional” at the time where simply seeing things in a way others around them didn’t have the capacity or foresight to”
McCullen said it’s possible for any woman to build her own Second Shelf. Step one: choose a woman writer that speaks to you, and start by acquiring her first editions over time, saving up for more expensive additions or asking for them as birthday gifts. “It seems like a nostalgic or precious pursuit, at first,” McCullen says. “I think women are very practical with their money. They’re worried about the day-to-day. Book collecting just seems like a little bit of a frivolous endeavor. But when you actually look at the issue at hand—which is that women aren’t collected and women’s voices don’t take as much room physically on shelves—then you see it as a mission and a purpose. And that your pursuit of these books can actually make a difference.”
McCullen’s
passion is certainly infectious, by the time I walked out of the Second Self, I
found that I bought three novels on her recommendation. I even grabbed a books
on some local legends and I’m seriously considering starting a collection; just
have to find the right author. And, for now, at least, a female-focused
literary collection comes at a reasonable price. “The threshold is lower
because their books are less money. So, at
this moment, it’s a good time to start your collection.” And she has just the
place to go.


